Friday, August 12, 2011

Beware the Beast

Have you all calmed down now? Apparently not! The politicians and the media commentators are all having a field day with recriminations, blame, knee jerk reactions and ill-advised “analyses” of why the #riots happened and what to do about it. Summary, but not exhaustive:

It’s all about inequality.
      So, please explain why the privileged are also prone to this sort of behaviour – the Bullingdon club and that nice Mr Clegg you keep reminding us about?

It’s the coalition cuts to youth services and youth clubs.
      So, please explain why those youths who avail themselves of Youth clubs were tucked up in bed while those who don’t were out on the streets?

It’s all to do with lack of opportunity, exclusion and poverty.
      So, please explain how the rioters all had Blackberries and were wearing Nike Trainers?

The youth of today are the product of the last Labour Government.
      So, please explain what role their parents played? They were the product of a Conservative government.

It’s too much Liberalism brought in by the last Labour Government.
      So, please explain the riots that occurred before that happened?

It’s too much commercialisation and consumerism.
      Again, please explain the riots that occurred before that happened?

The moral decay is led from the top.
      So, did we not know there was corruption at the top until last Saturday?

I’ll stop there, that’s enough to get the picture. The fact is that all of these things are legitimate topics for debate but have nothing whatsoever to do with what we have witnessed over the past week. And what’s really worrying is that I fear the politicians don’t know this and will just do what they did last time, business as usual, which will make it even more likely that it will not only be repeated more frequently but the impact will be even worse.

If you want to understand the riots, you first have to understand the language they are written in. That language is Mathematics. More specifically, Chaos Theory. Chaos produces clusters – I distinctly remember learning this in Primary School, but I don’t suppose they teach that anymore.

Think about what we witnessed on our TV screens. Looting (that’s burglary), vandalism, arson, muggings, confrontation with the Police, graffiti, Knife crime….. These are all everyday occurrences in most communities, some more than others, but they are spread out and mostly containable. Look at your local press. What Chaos does is to concentrate those things into a short period of time in specific locations and triggered (no pun intended) by the butterfly effect which gives rise to herd mentality.

That’s how Nature works. We forget at our peril that we are all part of that natural system, each of us small atoms rushing around in a giant test tube we know as the Earth. That we can think and rationalise does not mean we can control, merely attempt to understand.

By their very nature those triggers are unpredictable, so we know these things will happen again and again, not when or how often, but whatever our social conditions and whatever political ideology is prevalent at the time.

What to do? Well, we behave like boy scouts. We recognise the danger and we prepare to deal with these outbreaks swiftly, effectively, compassionately and reasonably. Not much to ask is it?

Of course I may be talking out of my arse. WTF do I know?

"Let him who has understanding calculate the number of the beast, for the number is that of man; and his number is six hundred and sixty-six" Revelation 13:16-18.

6 comments:

  1. First half great
    Second total bollocks, pardon my french

    You are, as you suspect, talking right out of your arse, but thank god for some originality! It's the most interesting interpretation I've read by a mile and much better than all those idiots just attributing their petty political bugbears as the causes.

    More?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just delete the "It's all" and you're about there. Like it on not we live in a socio-economic system, were everything is influenced by, and is influenced by, everything else. So it's all of the above.

    In other words, Chaos Theory. Like what you say. So you are talking out of your mouth.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Doc,
    I had noticed that you mentioned Chaos Theory on your blog and in this context too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It'smore like the second law of thermodynamics wre everything moves from a state of order to one of chaos

    ReplyDelete
  5. Of course it's not "all" one thing or another that gives rise to events like the riots. And I'm sure that chaos theory does have something to do whether a particular incident sparks a riot, whether the riot leads on to looting etc. But I think you probably can say that the prevalence of such events during particular periods varies because of sociological factors.

    I vaguely remember skimming through Durkheim's "Suicide", in which he relates the prevalence of suicide in different societies to sociological factors such as the dominant religious beliefs (either protestant of catholic). Each incidence had its unique causal factors relating to the individual. But somehow the vulnerability of the individual was influenced by overarching societal factors. Does this have any relevance?

    This year I visited Gloucester & Cheltenham while I was on holiday, never having been to either before. While Cheltenham looked as generally prosperous as I expected I was surprised at how parts of Gloucester city centre looked. So I was not surprised to see reports of some trouble in Gloucester but none from Cheltenham.

    Yours, confused Dave.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Confused Dave,
    We are all products of social conditioning, but it is a variable depending upon our position within the social structure. That's what makes it confusing.
    Confused Weggis.

    Hey you're not the PM are you?

    ReplyDelete